This week’s Beautiful Shame Story is from Amy Oestreicher – a performer, artist, writer, and public speaker who has used creativity to celebrate her life’s many traumas. She refers to these traumas as “detours” that she has navigated with creative expression to grow stronger and more beautiful. We are honored to share her story.
I know that on the inside and out, I am beautiful.
I’ve also felt shame – undeservedly – and it took a long time to realize that it was shame that did not befit me.
I gave a TEDx Talk last year about how all of the twists and turns have made me who I am, and it was then that I realized that the path my life has taken is what makes life beautiful. It’s the twists and turns that make me who I am – and those twists and turns have also caused me deep shame. But when that shame was brought to light, I realized it wasn’t shame at all. It was my fear of the power I had within me, all along.
Gutless and Grateful
Years after my medical and emotional traumas, I wrote a musical about my life, Gutless and Grateful. Again, my sharing my story, I realized I was beautiful for what I went through – and all shame disappeared with the spotlight that I had been passionate about ever since I was a child. And I will continue to heal and embody my beauty, my #beautifulshame, by sharing my story.
Sexual Abuse and Trauma
I’ve been through multiple traumas over the past decade, and it has taken me that long to learn to share. When I speak at colleges about my own story of sexual abuse, I never forget how difficult it was for me to even speak the words, “I was sexually abused.” It took me an even longer time to believe it, or to understand it could happen to me. And what took so much longer than I ever could have predicted, was to believe that I was sexually abused…and it wasn’t my fault.
Many survivors “know” that being sexually assaulted was not their fault. Now, I’m one of them. But the question I’ve worked to answer after a decade of “healing” and “processing” what happened to me is, “Well, then why didn’t I do something?”
I had heard this dozens and dozens of times — in my own head and with students who have opened up to me during my programs. Many victims of abuse, molestation and domestic violence often feel a guilt that they are not deserving of. For months after my voice teacher molested me, I beat myself up thinking, “Why did I do that?” wondering, “What was I thinking?” and assuming “Something must be wrong with me.”
It also took me a very long time to accept that a mentor and father figure in my life had violated our trusting relationship. I kept replaying the events that had occurred in my mind, telling myself, I must have done something wrong — why else would he have done this? I must have instigated something… I blamed myself, convinced that no one could take advantage of me if I had not invited it.
Shame and Numbness
I couldn’t shake off the “shame” I felt no matter how hard I tried to forget what had happened. The more I tried to block my memories, the more anxious and confused I became. I became a space cadet — hardly feeling at all. It was how I protected myself. This way, I couldn’t feel the sense of loss and betrayal. I couldn’t feel the shame of still thinking this was all “my fault.” My numbness started to alarm my friends and family, to whom I insisted that nothing was wrong at all. I kept this secret hidden inside, burning in my gut, hidden from those I loved.
The more I tried to repress what had happened, the more anxious I became, until I couldn’t handle keeping these secrets locked up so tightly. Shocked, upset, and overwhelmed, I was living in three worlds. Part of me was functioning normally in school, keeping up my grades, and telling people I was “fine.” Part of me was replaying traumatic memories in my head, beating myself up for not saying no, for not running away, for not fighting back. And part of me was in a numb, apathetic space of disconnect — a place I created in my head as a survival instinct. If I created a frozen, “numb” space to exist in, it was as though I could alleviate the sense of shame I felt.
When I turned 18, I finally spilled everything to my mother. I was so afraid of what she might say or if she would judge my actions. I was embarrassed to say words like “sex” and “molestor” and “rape” out loud, let alone with my mother. My mother was as shocked I was, but she still provided me with the one solid anchor that I needed:
She told me it was not my fault. No matter what I told her I had done, what he had done, what details I could remember, or what I confided in her, she reassured me with the certainty only a mother can have: it was not your fault.
Reaching out to someone I knew who loved me unconditionally, calmed my anxiety. Telling someone what had happened made my “dark” secret come to light. I became open to viewing my abuse in a different way — I was willing to take some of the responsibility off of myself. My mother and I started reading about “trauma.”
I learned that in the face of trauma, you can have three responses: You can fight, flee or freeze. I could have immediately fought back against my abuser, yelling “no” or defying him in some way. I could have just ran in the other direction as fast as I could. But I was so shocked by everything that happened, that I froze. Like a deer in the headlights, I couldn’t come to terms with the idea that a man that I trusted as my mentor could turn into such a monster in the blink of an eye. I mentally left the situation, disassociated from my body, and became a passive bystander to a trauma that my body was directly involved in.
The Stress of Shame
I learned that the physical sensations of “guilt” register in the same way that “shame” and “helplessness” do in your body — so when a person feels helpless in a situation, the body automatically pairs that sensation with “guilt.” When you undergo any kind of trauma, it causes a disturbance in your energy flow — suddenly, you are unable to feel those emotions that once came so naturally at a time. My body stopped breathing the same way it used to — a big knot of tension evolved in my chest and remained there like a cocoon. My thoughts became rigid — frightened to wander into past memories. I put up a daze like four safe walls that protected me from being consciously present in the abuse, and that daze stayed with me with or without him. I lived in a world separate from everyone else.
Reaching out not only gave me the blessing of compassion from others — it also informed me of what I had really experienced. I realized my “numb” response to my assault, my nervous energy, sweating fits and anxiety attacks were not something to be ashamed of, but rather, a proud and victorious survival strategy.
In a wonderful book, Waking the Tiger, Peter Levine writes,
“All mammals automatically regulate survival responses from the primitive, non-verbal brain, mediated by the autonomic nervous system. Under threat, massive amounts of energy are mobilized in readiness for self-defense via the fight, flight, and freeze responses. Once safe, animals spontaneously ‘discharge’ this excess energy through involuntary movements including shaking, trembling, and deep spontaneous breaths. This discharge process resets the autonomic nervous system, restoring equilibrium.”
Suddenly, I felt understood. Now when I work with survivors, I help them realize that their reactions to trauma and assault are natural human reactions to be applauded. The real work comes from taking that nervous energy, which was formerly an essential trauma survival skill, and turning it into productive healing energy — energy that once redirected, can build a new, beautiful world for the survivor.
Survivors and Creativity
As a proud, once-frozen survivor, I can finally see my world in color again. It happened once I could find the courage to feel the sensations of being alive — however uncomfortable it might have felt in moments of trauma, guilt, shame and confusion. I protected myself in a traumatic situation by becoming numb to my emotions, but now the danger was gone, and my abuser had left the picture long ago. Now, the work was up to me. I told myself “it wasn’t my fault” until I believed it. And once I felt these words resonate in my body, in my soul — I liberated myself. I had nothing to be ashamed of. And I had every right to reclaim my life, my aliveness, move on and experience the world in all of its radiant colors once again.
The biggest gift I can give to survivors I work with in my program now, is the gift of a world in color — alive with melancholy blues, angry reds, uncertain grays, but also one of ecstatic oranges, bright yellows, and deep rich purples. Once we let ourselves feel the “bad”, we make room for the “good”.
I was sexually abused. It was not my fault. In a traumatizing situation, I froze, while others might have fled or fought back. But with time and with confiding in those I trust, I have unthawed and faced what I’ve tried to forget. And with nothing to hide, nothing to regret or redo, and everything to look forward to in the future, I’ve allowed myself to move on, claiming my voice, speaking my truth.
As survivors, the most wonderful part of healing is moving from a helpless situation into a world of our own design. Beccause we’ve relied on the instinctual survival skill of freezing, we’ve kept our spirits in tact, and now, we’re unstoppable.
So what is shame? Shame is energy. As we turn that energy into energy that is rightfully ours, the energy of survival, pride and life, we become forces to be reckoned with.
All artwork was created by Amy on her detour. Learn about her speaking, or catch her touring Gutless & Grateful, her one woman musical, to theatres, colleges, conferences and organizations nationwide. Learn about her mental health advocacy programs for students, and find out how to take part in the#LoveMyDetour movement, and learn about her upcoming book, My Beautiful Detour at http://amyoes.com. Please also take a moment to endorse Amy for a Health Activist Award!
Do you have a #BeautifulShame Story that you want to share? Send an email to firstname.lastname@example.org that outlines: 1). Your struggle 2). How you’ve used creativity as an outlet to deal with it 3). How you feel now. — Feel free to include photos, videos, music, poetry, or anything else!